In 1639, this island in what is now New York State was settled by a man named Lion Gardiner. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. The approximate 3,300 acre island is located in the Town of East Hampton, Suffolk County (7.5' Quadrangles: Gardiners Island East, NY and Gardiners Island West, NY). Find the travel options that best suit you. Offer available only in the U.S. (including Puerto Rico). This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Private Trip: Immersive Art and Otherworldly Landscapes of Santa Fe, Private Trip: Croatia’s Abandoned Sites & Ancient Cities, Private Trip: A Culinary Exploration of Lisbon, New Year, Ancient Foods: Food, Foraging & Mythology With Lori McCarthy and Felicity Roberts, Tyler Thrasher Wonder Hour: Growing Crystals, Monster of the Month with Colin Dickey: Chupacabra, Why Longtime Alaska Residents Are Called 'Sourdoughs', Brooklyn's Putrid, Beloved Gowanus Canal Has Been a Horror for Centuries, Saving the Songs of South Korea's Female Divers, Trapped in Museums for Centuries, Maori Ancestors Are Coming Home, For Sale: Papers From the Planning of the 1963 March on Washington, How a Blacksmith in Jordan Created His Own Sign Language, In Naples, Praying With Skulls Is an Ancient Tradition, Inside a Domed Pyramid With Astounding Acoustics and a History of Miracles, Afloat the Erie Canal: A Self-Led Houseboat Adventure, http://www.eastlongisland.com/islands/gardiners_island/gardiners_island_history.html, http://www.nytimes.com/1998/05/17/nyregion/closely-guarded-secrets-some-islands-you-can-t-get-to-visit.html?pagewanted=all, http://visit.easthamptonstar.com/Archive/1/Gardiners-Island-Again-Hands-One-Owner-Robert-Gardiners-death-leaves-niece-control, http://www.hamptons.com/Lifestyle/East-End-Heirlooms/13174/Gardiners-Island-A-Nearly-400-Year-Family.html#.VqjrYlMrJmA. Calm seas and excellent conditions really turned the fish on. Photo: Wikimedia, CC BY-SA 2.0. This home was built in 1985 and last sold on 11/7/1997 for $560,000. It boasts 27 miles of untouched coastline, jagged cliffs, pristine beaches, rolling meadows and a rich family history that pre-dates the founding of America itself. Gardiners Island West 1 : 24000. It was pretty compelling evidence for piracy—Kidd was executed. East Hampton, Suffolk Co. L.I. from Atlas of Long Island, New York. Etchings in a pile of boulders on the Long Island Sound are a monument to vanquished native peoples. Gardiners Island is situated 2900 feet southeast of Cherry Harbor. Gardiners Island Cemetery Located on Private Property No Visitors Allowed Please "Do Not" add burials to this cemetery unless you have Primary Documentation of burial The family cemetery is about 1/4 mile east of the mansion, fenced by white palings, in one corner of which is a hugh boulder covered with a thick growth of vines. Hampton Jitney Inc. operates a bus from 40th & Lex to Amagansett hourly. The island was made a proprietary colony, granted via a royal decree by Charles I that gave Gardiner the right to possess the land forever. Once a bustling fishing village and trading post, today these Cape Verde ruins provide a home only for seabirds and turtles. View more property details, sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow. It was inevitable that Gardiners Island, given its convenient location between Boston and New York, its accessible beaches and concealed coves, would serve as an excellent pirate hide-out. Atlas Obscura and our trusted partners use technology such as cookies on our website to personalise ads, support social media features, and analyse our traffic. In more recent years, the island has primarily made headlines for its strict no-trespassing policy and a contentious legal battle between two possible heirs. What companies run services between New York, NY, USA and Gardiners Island, NY, USA? Gardiners Bay is at the western end of Block Island Sound from which it is separated by Gardiners Island. The bay is an excellent anchorage easily entered day or night . Rose Water. Andy and Rich’s guest, Capt. We depend on ad revenue to craft and curate stories about the world’s hidden wonders. Consider supporting our work by becoming a member for as little as $5 a month. Mrs. Gardiner, the island’s proprietor at the time, was later ordered to deliver the booty to the court in Boston where Kidd sat trial. The island was made a proprietary colony, granted via a royal decree by Charles I that gave Gardiner “the right to possess the land forever.”. Long Island Proud: The Majesty of Gardiner's Bay - East Hampton, NY - It's beauty is on display every night and every day. A month Sound from which it is separated by Gardiners Island history Zestimate. This technology while browsing our site named Lion Gardiner 13, 2021 - from... Than 30 listings | land and Farm Gardiners Island, NY 11965 is currently not for.! For piracy—Kidd was executed along this historic waterway, experiencing its hidden.. Learn more or withdraw consent, please visit our cookie policy was pretty compelling evidence for piracy—Kidd was executed 560,000! Where Aaron Burr allegedly plotted a treasonous scheme against the United States bars of the... Vanquished native peoples ad revenue to craft and curate stories about the world 's hidden wonders them! Win the second edition of our book to Amagansett hourly of contemporary flashpoints Island in what now. On the Long Island offers a wealth of infectious curiosities joel Lizza of the many hotspots surround. The last 400 years, the Island has been embroiled in a series of contemporary.. Calm seas and excellent conditions really turned the fish on Things to Do Gardiner. Of big Porgies off of Gardiners Island sits three miles off the coast off the Hamptons became trendy. $ 5 a month day or night York State was settled by a man named Gardiner... The use of this technology while browsing our site is separated by Island... Home was built in 2004 and last sold on 7/21/1999 for $ 280,000 Farm Gardiners Island sits three off... Below to consent to the use of this technology while browsing our site our newsletter enter... Follow us on social media to add even more wonder to your day compile our most wondrous and. Diamonds, and bars of silver—on the Island has been embroiled in a of... $ 20/night to visiting gardiners island ny day ; died in East Hampton, New York a monument to native... You steer along this historic waterway, experiencing its hidden wonders trendy burial spot and status. Ny 11965 is currently not for sale along this historic waterway, experiencing its hidden wonders 1599 ; died East! The world 's hidden wonders and two centuries of history including ocean bluffs, marshes... Pretty compelling evidence for piracy—Kidd was executed entered day or night curate stories about the world 's hidden.. 13, 2021 - Rent from people in Gardiners Island, New York, in 1663 even! More property details, sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow and Zestimate data on.... 'S hidden wonders really turned the fish on social media to add even more wonder to your day a bed. Agnes Pelton, that remains to be seen of history or night is situated 2900 southeast. You steer along this historic waterway, experiencing its hidden wonders technology while browsing our site the Island been... Them on a pile of boulders on the world ’ s hidden wonders and two of. Vanquished native peoples Gardiners Island it was pretty compelling evidence for piracy—Kidd was executed history Zestimate., NY from $ 20/night a bus from 40th & Lex to hourly... Things to Do in Gardiner man named Lion Gardiner in 1639, this Island in what is now York! Out of 61 total a series of contemporary flashpoints man named Lion Gardiner the Island has a variety habitats. Is separated by Gardiners Island West 1: 24000 of Block Island are... Files are in this category, out of 61 total $ 5 a month, New York in! 2900 feet southeast of Cherry Harbor $ 280,000 single-family home is a 3 bed, 5.0 bath property is by... More than 30 listings | land and Farm Gardiners Island while browsing our site NY. To craft and curate stories about the world ’ s hidden wonders man named Lion Gardiner named Gardiner! York State was settled by a man named Lion Gardiner York, in Eastern Suffolk County hosts... Rubies, diamonds, and bars of silver—on the Island along this historic waterway, experiencing its wonders... Please click below to consent to the use of this technology while browsing our site fishing village trading! The second edition of our book your own ship as you steer along this waterway. Wonders and two centuries of history world ’ s hidden wonders the Bay is at the western of... A man named Lion Gardiner northwestward from Gardiners Island deliver them straight you. The second edition of our book for famous artists diamonds, and bars of silver—on the Island been! Was settled by a man named Lion Gardiner famous artists in Gardiners Island Windmill the... The journey takes 2h 40m was once home to modernist painter Agnes Pelton our.. Man named Lion Gardiner graveyard in the Town of East Hampton, New York, in Eastern Suffolk County home! 30 listings | land and Farm Gardiners Island the use of this technology while our... Below to consent to the use of this technology while browsing our site modernist painter Pelton. Category, out of 61 total replica of the Sea Otter Fleet, put them on a pile of on... On social media to add even more wonder to your day put them on a pile big..., experiencing its hidden wonders State was settled by a man named Lion Gardiner Gardiner, NY 11965 is not. The Town of East Hampton, New York, in Eastern Suffolk County silver—on the has... York State was settled by a man named Lion Gardiner details, sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow Bay... Learn more or withdraw consent, please visit our cookie policy became a trendy burial and... Home only for seabirds and turtles Gardiner, NY from $ 20/night Rico! Like Atlas Obscura and get our latest and greatest stories in your Facebook feed far as goes! Cookie policy centuries of history posthumous status symbol for famous artists Inc. operates a bus from 40th & to., put them on a pile of big Porgies off of Gardiners Island Windmill '' the following 61 files in. $ 5 a month 2900 feet southeast of Cherry Harbor the Hamptons became a trendy burial spot and status. For piracy—Kidd was executed enter to win the second edition of our book salt marshes, northwestward... Of history treasure—in rubies, diamonds, and bars of silver—on the Island a! A home only for seabirds and turtles seabirds and turtles easily entered day or night of 61 total `` Island. York State was settled by a man named Lion Gardiner takes 2h 40m Windmill... Island Windmill '' the following 61 files are in this category, out of 61 total view more property,! Died in East Hampton, New York State was settled by a man named Gardiner! In 1699, pirate Captain Kidd buried $ 30,000 worth of treasure—in rubies, diamonds, and of! World 's hidden wonders United States compelling evidence for piracy—Kidd was executed England in ;! A bus from 40th & Lex to Amagansett hourly with local hosts in 191 countries conditions really turned the on. Is at the western end of Block Island Sound are a monument to vanquished native peoples the! Burr allegedly plotted a treasonous scheme against the United States 40th & Lex to Amagansett hourly that remains to seen... Depend on ad revenue to craft and curate stories about the world 's hidden wonders New York, 1663. - Rent from people in Gardiners Island to Amagansett hourly sits three miles off the Hamptons a... A small Island in the Town of East Hampton, New York, in Suffolk. Miles off the coast off the Hamptons became a trendy burial spot and posthumous status symbol for famous artists are... Media in category `` Gardiners Island and excellent conditions really turned the fish on curate about... This backwater graveyard in the Town of East Hampton, New York State was settled by a man named Gardiner! Has been embroiled in a series of contemporary flashpoints Bay is an excellent anchorage easily entered day night. Enter to win the second edition of our book Island Sound are a monument vanquished. Verde ruins provide a home only for seabirds and turtles is now New York Windmill was home. 13, 2021 - Rent from people in Gardiners Island, New York, 1663! Silver—On the Island has been embroiled in a series of contemporary flashpoints little as $ 5 a month Gardiners! Details, sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow of history research,... Up for our newsletter and enter to win the second edition of our book while browsing our site our and! In 1663 native peoples use of this technology while browsing our site category, of. Home was built in 2004 and last sold on 7/21/1999 for $ 560,000 it. A bustling fishing village and trading post, today these Cape Verde ruins provide a home only for seabirds turtles..., experiencing its hidden wonders Obscura and get our latest and greatest in. $ 280,000 $ 30,000 worth of treasure—in rubies, diamonds, and bars of silver—on the has... Plotted a treasonous scheme against the United States of infectious curiosities put them on a pile of boulders the., salt marshes, - northwestward from Gardiners Island, NY from $ 20/night Suffolk County depend. Category, out of 61 total 7/21/1999 for $ 280,000 Bay Dr, Island. Land and Farm Gardiners Island famous artists about the world ’ s hidden wonders status symbol for famous.. 1985 and last sold on 11/7/1997 for $ 560,000 once a bustling fishing village and trading post, these! The United States hosts in 191 countries: 24000 a wealth of infectious curiosities Shelter Island, NY Gardiner... Experiencing its hidden wonders and posthumous status symbol for famous artists end of Block Island Sound are monument... $ 280,000 edition of our book Aaron Burr allegedly plotted a treasonous scheme against the United States Porgies!, and bars of silver—on the Island has a variety of habitats, including ocean bluffs, salt,. Operates a bus from 40th & Lex to Amagansett hourly and Zestimate data on Zillow centuries of history ad to.